If there is no Compulsion in Islam then why is a Muslim who leaves Islam put to Death – Zakir Naik
If there is no Compulsion in Islam then why is a Muslim who leaves Islam put to Death – Dr Zakir Naik
SBICQA-3
#Compulsion #Islam #Islaam #Muslim #leaves #Death #Zakir #Naik #Zakirnaik #Drzakirnaik #Dr #Drzakirchannel #Allah #Allaah #God #Comparative #Religion #ComparativeReligion #Atheism #Atheist #Christianity #Christian #Hinduism #Hindu #Buddhism #Buddhist #Judaism #Jew #Sikhism #Sikh #Jainism #Jain #Lecture #Question #Answer #QuestionsandAnswer #Logic #Reason #Science #Misconception #Misunderstanding #PeaceTV #Dawah #Muhammad #Mohammed #Hadeeth #Hadith #Saheeh #Sahih #Man #Woman #Human #Humanity #Problem #Solution #Rights #Media #War #Peace #Similarities #Debate #Lecture #Quran #Quraan #AlQuran #AlQuraan #Bible #Veda #Gita #Geeta #Baghwat #Upanishad #Purana #Terrorism #Terrorist #Universal #Brotherhood #Word #Purpose #Life #Jihad #Jihaad #Jesus #Christ #Jesuschrist #Church #Mosque #Masjid #Perspective #Ask #AskDrZakir #Seeking #Knowledge #Education #NonMuslim #Fundamentalist #Fundamentalism #Symposium #Dialogue #Salaah #Salah #Shariah #Scripture #Ahmed #Deedat #AhmedDeedat #Daee #Missionary #pewdiepie #asmr #music #markiplier #oldtownroad #pewdiepievstseries #billieeilish #fortnite #Concept #West #Family #Global #Ramadhaan #Ramadan #Tauheed #Tawheed #Monotheism #Zakaat #Zakat #Zakah #Hajj #Saum #Fasting #Makkah #Mecca #Madinah #India #Malaysia #Ummah #Unity #Importance #Date #Isamophobia #Understand #Deen #Fardh #Fard #Haraam #Haram #Sunnah #Mustahab #Waajib #Wajib #Compulsory #Prohibited #Encouraged #Permissible #Permitted #Prohibited #Sin #Sinful #Heaven #Hell #Hellfire #Jannah #Jahannum #Paradise
source
Dude has the dumbest comparison ever stated. Leaking state secrets to an enemy state and treason of a country is not the same as leaving a religion.
This man thinks he's talking to fools๐
The idea that the death penalty for apostasy is only related to treason is a view strongly supported by many modern scholars and reformist Muslims.
The following arguments strengthen this view:
The factors that can be linked to treason
1. The principle of freedom in the Quran
The principle of "There is no compulsion in religion" in the Quran (2:256) fully recognizes the freedom of belief of the individual. Therefore, punishing a person solely for religious beliefs is contrary to this principle.
2. The history and context of the hadith
The hadiths that call for the death penalty for apostasy can be seen as having been issued at a time when the Muslim community was at war and the security of the nascent state was threatened.
* In those times, apostasy (leaving Islam) often meant turning against the community and joining the enemy, Or associated with the formation of militant organizations.
* Therefore, the punishment is more often referred to as a punishment for harming the state (Treason/Seditions) than a religious punishment.
3. The Quran does not mention worldly punishments
Although the Quran specifically mentions worldly punishments (e.g., whipping, amputation) for certain crimes such as theft and adultery, it does not mention the punishment for apostasy in this world. The Quran emphasizes that the consequences of apostasy are related to the afterlife.
Therefore, the death penalty for apostasy is not a punishment for abandoning one's faith, but Modern scholars see the argument that it could only be a punishment intended for serious acts that threaten the stability and security of the Islamic state (treason) as more logical and consistent with the Quran's principle of religious freedom.
What then is the definition of a secret cult?
Zakir naik and muslim friends, i have a question for you all, if muslim leave and put to death, how can Allah forgive him if hes not repented? Does Allah hates people life test gets sabotaged that he can't forgive that this man not repented yet? that onlyman ruined his life was to kill him? Do you see the problem here?
Once you leave islam, you will be headed
Why is most groups forcing people to be in there faith or they are killed
Zakia naik, Is a potato, he doesn't know what he's talking about, ๐๐.๐
Ma Sha Allah โค
What a beautiful way you have used to explain this issue
Allah pak apko bhht bhht ajar ata farmayn ameenโค
And we are supposed to believe Islam is peaceful, it is faith based, right? The answer uses state rules as reference to justify the doctrine of a (supposedly) peaceful faith. Read history and you will see paragraphs after paragraphs Muslim's showing pride for converting people to Islam at the point of sword.
To cover up the lies of false prophet Muhammad saws
Aah Zakir naik with his nonsense again. His fans must be the most stupidest people on earth
Quran didn't say anything for a person to be punished if he left from his religion- But what Dr. Zakir said something else by giving an example of treason where to some extent the capital punishment is inevitable under the law of the land but which is not applicable here if one leave from his faith.
Dr. Zakir cleverly avoided to give a clear answer.
I doubt my Islam religion because of apostasy law
wow so no wonder they all go and pray every friday because the neighbor might grass them up end up getting killed wow yea this must be the religion of peace, you cant force anyone into the religion but you can make them pay additional taxes and treat then like slaves, the more i hear about islam the more im starting to understand it – in short it should be banned world wide
you muslims are ANIIIIMAAAALSSSSSS
The speaker did not answer the question. The questioner pointed out a contradiction, i.e., (1) There is no compulsion in religion and (2) The punishment of apostasy is death.
'No compulsion in religion' means that a person may choose to accept it or not accept it. Also, a person may choose to accept it now and later rejects it. Also, a person may choose to reject it now and later accepts it. That's what it means by 'No compulsion in religion'.
I don't find 'death' as the punishment of apostasy in Quran.
May Allah swt give him highest level in jannah.Ameen
ยน If he really wanted to give clear answers, then he wouldn't talk so fast nor slur English so badly that the words are unrecognizable
ยฒ Apparently you CAN compel them to applaud however, just like N. Korea.
ยณ I pity those ppl & pray they escape that death cult holding them captive with fear. ๐โ๏ธ Jesus Christ is Lord Godโฃ๏ธ
Zakir twisted the question and gave a false answer. It does not say to kill Muslim that leaves Islam only when he commits blasphemy. In Quran it only says that any Muslim that discards his religion, kill him. This is how zakir propagated Islam to be a real religion. ๐
Islam is aproblem religeon reality confuse people and some convert blindly but truth is violent reoligeon
So if his son wants to jump from a story building, in order not to let him die, he can just take a knife and stab his son to death?
If you dont obey the rules of a school, you get expelled, not killed.
Its only a cult that kills people when they want to leave.
I hope that the eyes of people open and the see that they are worshipping an enslaver not a god.
You compare someone with a simple change in personal preference of association to someone who commits treason? Oh damn! Who made you a Dr ?
We are all created free!!! ALL PEPEL ARE FREE DOCTORRRR!!!! ANYONE WHO LEAVES ISLAM WILL BE KILLED BECAUSE ISLAM ARE SCARED THAT THEIR BAD SMELL IN THAT SEX CULT RELIGION WILL BE EXPOSED. THAT'S WHY NOW… MANY MUSLIMS WERE LEAVING ISLAM. EXPLAIN HOW THE GOVERNMENT OF SYRIA KILLING NON MUSLIMS SUCH AS DRUZE AND CHRISTIANS? NOT BECAUSE OF SOME PF THEM WERE ISRAELI, BUT SOME OF THEM WERE AUSTRALIAN, AMERICAN, I SAW A VIDEO THAT THE SYRIAN ARMIES MAKING FOND OF THEM, I SAW THEY TORTURE MEN AND INSISTED TO L SAY AWWW AWWW.. PIGS!!! SAY AWW AWWW AWWW!???, TAKING GIRLS, RAPED THEM AND MAKE THEM AS THEIR SEX SLAVES.. STUPID ISLAM!!!! YOUR RELIGION DOESN'T HAVE PEACE!!! WITHOUT LIES ISLAM DIES โคโคโคโคโคโค
๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐
How do you receive converts/apostates from other religions but you kill your own apostates, ie those who leave Islam?
Free to enter but not free to leave…
THIS IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CHRISTIANITY AND THE OTHER TWO ISLAM AND JUDIASM…
ISLAM AND JUDIASM LOOK BACK WARD WHILE CHRISTIANITY LOOK FORWARD.
JESUS DOES NOT TRYING TO CORRECT THE PREVIOUS LAWS OF MOSES ETC. BUT BRINGING THE FAITH TO THE NEW ERA, A NEW COVENANT, WHERE SALVATION ARE NOT BASED ON STRICT LAWS OR FOLLOWING SPECIFIC TRADITIONS BUT BASED ON GOOD ACTIONS AND GENUINE ALLEGIANCE TO GOD.
Islam is not the religion of peace. It has barbaric laws and practices. SMH.
Maybe the reason islam is so successful is because it is so fucking stupid and justbtells you what you have to do, without asking why. I camt believe ppl are statisfied with this answer. He basically says that, if there is islamic law than it is admitted, if not not. This is a compelling argument for letting islam never to spread
The mafia way, once you enter you cannot leave
so why not quote the sura on this? Because u know if it comes to light, people will leave islam.
Without lies, Islam dies.
I thank God for saving me from this Cult called Islam. Thank you Jesus. May u open up more eyes and let them see. We will spread the truth.
They brainwash us to Islam and when we realize it for what it is, they keep us in prison by threats like this…..
Absolute Nonsense.
And Islam does force people to join Islam for protection, text or kill u if u do not accept.
Its all in the quran.
What kind of god gives u a book without instructions on how to evwn do the 5prayers but relies on another book to explain the rules… ๐๐๐๐.
One thats a lier!
God is truth and no contradiction.
This dude ๐
Badly answered. Leaving Islam doesn't necessarily equate to advocating against it or being subversive against it. Nowhere in the Qur'an does it state leaving the Faith must result in the apostate receiving capital punishment! Precisely because the PRINCIPLE of free will is central to Islam and thus is upheld if someone should publicly choose to leave the faith. What is far worse is nifaq and slander which the Qur'an does Prescribe Punishment for, especially if the person refers to themselves as muslim!
Ok if a person leaves Christianity and becomes Muslim and his country kills him then would Muslims apply the same logic?
Religion is a personal matter it has nothing to do with leakage of top secrets because in that situation a person is causing harm but in leaving a religion there's absolutely no harm to anyone.
๐คก
This Imam is comparing Apples to Oranges. If a Person commits Treason in a Nation but giving up secrets, those secrets, in many cases, could get citizens killed. Changing our religious beliefs have no impact on others around us, near us or even related to us. So explain to me why it is necessary to KILL a person who leaves the Muslim Faith. If a Christian or Jew leaves their faith they are not killed for it. It is a personal choice. Do you not understand this? God bless you, and I truly hope your eyes will be opened and your mind as well.
Chapter 9 in Quran. Most violent chapter in quran. Quran ends their book with violence. No wonder, muslim are violent. Quran all about death.
The Quran says Jesus created life and that he is the wordโฆyall just copied Christianity and made it into your own version for your own personal desire. Clearly the people doing this never believed in a God or they worshipped Satan because if they truly feared God they wouldnโt deny his undeniable existing through The Son.
I think There is compulsion in Islam, Muslims are ordered to expand Islamic territory, ordered to attack non-Muslim countries, kings or leaders of non-Muslim countries will be offered to choose Islam or die.
Point #1 dont force anyone to accept islam
Point #2 if they become none muslims and starts to create his owm religiom or guide people to the wrong path or do bad things ,only then the punishment is death
Point #3. Every country has their own laws weather they allow killing of the person who leaves islam or not is entirely upto them, but as far as we know this rule isnt followed at all, nobody gets killed for leaving islam or dont get killed anymore.
What horrid and unconvincing argument. Christians donโt say this nor do Jews. This show how nasty Islam is. How anyone in the west is attracted to this beggars belief. God will be the judge. I am Christian: Jesus Christ is way, truth and life and preached love and compassion not violence. Many Muslims discover this and are in fear of their lives. We pray for them.
It is not written oppstady punishment in this world is death according to Quran and scholars argue if those hadis that come 100 years after prophet are true .
Why are ex muslims in hiding scared even from there families who have threatened to delete them??
Because Mohammed's ass got burnt when people started leaving his cult
Youโre an absolutely ridiculous human being.
Imagine those of us who were born into this faith, we never got a chance to choose it. And now weโre threatened with death if we leave it. Outrageous ๐
so leave now if you change your religion…freedom & democracy